Activism China Colonialism NED NGOs Technology

Hong Kong’s Poisoned Chalice | Dissident Voice

Hong Kong’s Poisoned Chalice | Dissident Voice

In chats about Hong Kong and the mainland, we all the time reached a consensus: if you wish to develop you’ll be able to go to the USA or again to the mainland, however there isn’t a future in Hong Kong.  In recent times, the decline has occurred with surprising velocity. At handover in 1997, per capita GDP was twice Macao’s. Hong Kong’s GDP was 18 % of China’s then; in 2013 it was three %. Now, Macau’s is 3 times Hong Kong’s. In 1997, neither Beijing, Shanghai nor Guangzhou had GDPs approaching Hong Kong’s; now all are greater, as are Shenzhen’s and Tianjin’s.

Demonstrators breaking into Hong Kong’s Legislative Council Chambers

The Good Previous Days

Underneath British rule,  Hong Kong’s public had no say in political appointment and the Governor, who was Commander in Chief of army forces, might do something in need of sentencing individuals to demise. Wiretaps didn’t require warrants; when police denied demonstration permits the courts might solely assessment their paperwork; the legislature was a rubber stamp and there was no political opposition. Underneath Communist “oppression”, the courts evaluate police selections for reasonableness, residents elect their legislators, the federal government has a political opposition, and the Chief Government can neither declare martial regulation nor name out the army. Some issues haven’t modified, nevertheless: it’s nonetheless unlawful in Hong Kong to hitch the Communist Get together of China.

Lacking Parts

Some features of up to date Hong Kong lacking from our media’s protection:

  1. So long as it managed entry to China’s gigantic market, Hong Kong flourished. Capitalism, Democracy, and British Justice had nothing to do with it.
  2. Had Hong Kong joined the mainland in 1997 its prosperity would have been assured.
  3. Earlier than the handover the UK launched electoral democracy, the poisoned chalice that ended the Colony’s hopes for improvement.
  4. When the Asian Monetary Disaster crashed actual property markets Chief Government Tung Chee-Hwa created the ‘85,000 Housing Improvement Undertaking’ to construct reasonably priced houses and diversify the financial system by constructing the Hong Kong Science Park and growing funding in commerce, schooling, business and tourism.
  5. As soon as the reasonably priced housing models got here onto the market the bourgeoisie opposed them as a result of they affected actual property costs, the laws voted with the bourgeoisie and the youth demonstrated of their help. Tung was vilified and thrown out.
  6. After they killed 224 individuals within the post-Tiananmen riots in 1989 French Intelligence, Britain’s MI6 and the CIA smuggled 600 brokers out by means of Hong Kong to Western nations. The PRC arrested three Hong Kong-based activists however launched them after intervention by the Hong Kong authorities.
  7. When China joined the WTO in 2001, commerce bypassed Hong Kong, stagnation set in and the town’s greatest and brightest joined Taiwanese in search of a greater life on the mainland.
  8. Hong Kong’s profile now resembles Britain’s: 23% of its youngsters stay in poverty– in comparison with the mainland’s 1%.
  9. Residence possession–a wedding prerequisite–fell from 53% in 2010 to 49% in 2018– in comparison with 78% on the mainland.
  10. Hong Kong trails solely London and New York for the most important focus of people value greater than $30 million.
  11. Hong Kong’s ten richest residents account for 35% of its GDP.
  12. Hong Kong’s family GINI is zero.539, Singapore’s is zero.458 in 2016, America’s is zero.394 and the UK’s is zero.358. (zero=equality).
  13. Lease for an HK ‘coffin condo’ is HK$2,000/mo.


Hong Kong’s woes illustrate capitalism’s acquainted  shortcomings: wealth accumulation has far outstripped the event of productive forces and the overwhelming majority of residents haven’t any solution to share its advantages. A big rentier class owns a lot of the metropolis’s social assets, the identical contradiction–between capital accumulation and society’s want to stay a dignified life–we confront within the US.

What do Hongkongers actually need? Financial progress, employment alternatives and higher housing, duties the mainland has already completed. If they need a vibrant future Hong Kongers have to work collectively more durable and convey their schooling requirements as much as the mainland’s. Their youth should develop a transparent understanding of their true associates and actual enemies.

The Protest Puzzle

The protests are fascinating for a number of causes:

  • They’re directed at Beijing, which does even have an extradition treaty with HK and has by no means requested one.
  • They’re timed (in all probability by the NED) to coincide with the anniversary of the handover.
  • They ignore the monetary establishments and capitalists blocking legislative change.
  • Western media cowl them sympathetically, virtually hysterically, whereas ignoring actual protests in Gaza, Honduras, Sudan, Yemen, and Brazil.
  • British media–which have persecuted, tortured, and incarcerated Julian Assange for non-political crimes–now urge his extradition, whereas trembling lest the PRC use ‘non-political crimes to prosecute critics.’
  • The UK Authorities has refused to promote crowd management gear to Hong Kong police.
  • Think about how the NYPD would reply if considered one of their officers have been assaulted like this:
  •  Or if demonstrators behaved like this: https://youtu.be/qFgE2Ardv64
  • Hong Kong police reported firing 150 tear fuel canisters, a number of rounds of rubber bullets and 20 beanbags in the course of the at some point of great violence, inflicting 72 accidents, none of which required hospitalization, and making 30 arrests.
  • French police, against this, fired 19,000 rubber bullets final yr and 5,400 shock grenades, brought on 850 critical accidents and 30 mutilations, dozens of facial and cranium fractures. Twelve French demonstrators misplaced one eye. Together with these injured by tear fuel, water cannon and truncheons, the quantity would strategy six figures, a degree of repression not seen because the German Occupation.
  • French police arrested 9,000 on March 24 alone, half of whom acquired jail sentences–and that was earlier than orders have been issued to arrest protesters even quicker.
  • The just about complete Western media silence about French figures has been matched with relentless propaganda presenting their demonstrators as damaging hooligans.

The NED: Doing God’s Work

Beijing’s completion of the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macao Bridge and the Hong Kong-Mainland high-speed railway, together with the relentless decline of voter help for ‘democracy’ events at each Hong Kong election are rushing the West’s ungraceful retreat from an Asia that by no means invited them. The extradition regulation will additional erode Western affect and speed up the political and financial integration of Hong Kong. Listed here are some parts of dis-integration:

  • There are 37,000 NGOs registered in Hong Kong (in comparison with 13,000 in Shanghai, which is 4 occasions bigger), lots of which obtain funding from the US and Europe.
  • In March 1997 the NED despatched their first survey mission to Hong Kong to evaluate the political setting and determine prospects for NED programming within the territory.
  • Fourteen NED survey missions had visited Hong Kong by 2012 to evaluate the political surroundings and determine prospects for NED programming.
  • In 2004, the NED discovered little curiosity amongst college college students in activism,2 “Many critics nonetheless lament the low degree of curiosity and activism by college college students in Hong Kong”.
  • Between 1995 – 2013, HKHRM acquired greater than $1.9 million in funds from the NED.
  • By way of its NDI and SC branches, NED has had shut relations with different teams in Hong Kong. SC has given $540,000 to the Hong Kong Confederation of Commerce Unions prior to now seven years.
  • The present protest’s messaging and its related teams increase questions on how natural the motion is:
  • A number of the teams obtain vital, direct funding from the NED.
  • The Canadian and British overseas ministries have publicly thrown their weight behind the protests.
  • The protesters attraction to Western audiences, utilizing indicators in English and the hashtag “AntiExtraditionLaw”.
  • The group under is waving colonial Hong Kong flags whereas accusing China of colonialism.

  • Preserving Hong Kong from China has been an American precedence for many years. One former CIA agent even admitted, “Hong Kong was our listening submit.”
  • Seventy worldwide NGOs have endorsed an open letter urging the invoice to be killed, however signed solely by Amnesty Worldwide, Human Rights Watch, and the Hong Kong Human Rights Monitor (HKHRM)–all US fronts.
  • In 2018, NED granted $155,000 to SC and $200,000 to NDI for work in Hong Kong, and $90,000 to HKHRM, which isn’t itself a department of NED however a companion in Hong Kong.
  • The coalition cited by Hong Kong media, together with the South China Morning Publish and the Hong Kong Free Press, lists as organizers of the demonstrations the Civil Human Rights Entrance. That group’s web site lists the NED-funded HKHRM, Hong Kong Confederation of Commerce Unions, the Hong Kong Journalists Affiliation, the Civic Social gathering, the Labour Get together, and the Democratic Social gathering as members of the coalition.
  • Since Beijing made an enormous deal of NED’s affect within the 2014 Occupy protests, it’s inconceivable that the present protest organizers are unaware of NED’s ties to its members. One NED official, Louisa Greve, informed the Voice of America that “activists know the dangers of working with NED companions” in Hong Kong.
  • Home Speaker Nancy Pelosi says Congress has “no selection however to reassess whether or not Hong Kong is ‘sufficiently autonomous’ beneath the ‘one nation, two techniques’ framework.”
  • The State Division says the extradition invoice might “might undermine Hong Kong’s autonomy and negatively impression the territory’s long-standing safety of human rights, elementary freedoms and democratic values.”
  • Martin Lee, founding father of Hong Kong’s Democratic Celebration, a member group of the Civil Human Rights Entrance, met with Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, who expressed help for the protests
  • Why are the protests supported by a overseas energy presently finishing up a coup in Venezuela, threatening the DPRK and making an attempt to start out a conflict with Iran?

The Precise Modification

The modification would “permit Hong Kong to give up fugitives on a case-by-case foundation to jurisdictions that don’t have long-term rendition agreements with the town,” amongst them mainland China and Taiwan. It was launched when authorities discovered that a Hong Kong man needed for murdering his pregnant girlfriend couldn’t be returned to Taiwan to face trial. Beneath present regulation, criminals from different elements of China can escape costs by fleeing to Hong Kong (think about if Louisiana, underneath its Napoleonic code, refused to extradite fugitives from Texas or California for crimes dedicated in these states). Underneath the modification the next crimes will probably be extraditable:

  • Aiding, abetting, counseling or procuring suicide.
  • Maliciously wounding; maiming; inflicting grievous or precise bodily hurt; assault occasioning precise bodily hurt; threats to kill; intentional or reckless endangering of life whether or not via a weapon, a harmful substance or in any other case; offences referring to illegal wounding or injuring.
  • Offences of a sexual nature together with rape; sexual assault; indecent assault; illegal sexual acts on youngsters; statutory sexual offences.
  • Gross indecency with a toddler, a psychological faulty or an unconscious individual.
  • Kidnapping; abduction; false imprisonment; illegal confinement; dealing or trafficking in slaves or different individuals; taking a hostage.
  • Felony intimidation.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to harmful medicine together with narcotics, psychotropic substances, precursors and important chemical compounds used within the unlawful manufacture of narcotics and psychotropic substances; offences referring to the proceeds of drug trafficking.
  • Acquiring property or pecuniary benefit by deception; theft; theft; housebreaking (together with breaking and getting into); embezzlement; blackmail; extortion; illegal dealing with or receiving of property; false accounting; some other offence in respect of property or fiscal issues involving fraud; any offence towards the regulation referring to illegal deprivation of property.
  • Offences towards chapter regulation or insolvency regulation.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to corporations together with offences dedicated by officers, administrators and promoters.
  • Offences referring to securities and futures buying and selling.
  • Offences referring to counterfeiting; offences towards the regulation referring to forgery or uttering what’s cast.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to safety of mental property, copyrights, patents or logos.
  • Offences referring to bribery, corruption, secret commissions and breach of belief.
  • Perjury and subornation of perjury.
  • Offences referring to the perversion or obstruction of the course of justice.
  • Arson; legal injury or mischief together with mischief in relation to pc knowledge.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to firearms.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to explosives.
  • Offences referring to environmental air pollution or safety of public well being.
  • Mutiny or any mutinous act dedicated on board a vessel at sea.
  • Piracy involving ships or plane.
  • Illegal seizure or train of management of an plane or different technique of transportation.
  • Genocide or direct and public incitement to commit genocide.
  • Facilitating or allowing the escape of an individual from custody.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to the management of exportation or importation of products of any sort, or the worldwide switch of funds.
  • Smuggling; import and export of prohibited gadgets, together with historic and archaeological gadgets.
  • Immigration offences together with fraudulent acquisition or use of a passport or visa.
  • Arranging or facilitating for monetary achieve, the unlawful entry of individuals right into a jurisdiction.
  • Offences referring to playing or lotteries.
  • Offences referring to the illegal termination of being pregnant.
  • Stealing, abandoning, exposing or unlawfully detaining a toddler; another offences involving the exploitation of youngsters.
  • Offences referring to prostitution and premises stored for the needs of prostitution.
  • Offences involving the illegal use of computer systems.
  • Offences referring to fiscal issues, taxes or duties.
  • Offences referring to illegal escape from custody; mutiny in jail.
  • Bigamy.
  • Offences referring to ladies and women.
  • Offences towards the regulation referring to false or deceptive commerce descriptions.
  • Offences referring to the possession or laundering of proceeds obtained from the fee of any offence described on this Schedule.
  • Impeding the arrest or prosecution of an individual who has or is believed to have dedicated an offence described on this Schedule.
  • Offences for which individuals could also be surrendered beneath multilateral worldwide conventions; offences created because of selections of worldwide organizations.
  • Conspiracy to commit fraud or to defraud.
  • Conspiracy to commit, or any sort of affiliation to commit, any offence described on this Schedule.
  • Aiding, abetting, counseling or procuring the fee of, inciting, being an adjunct earlier than or after the very fact to, or trying to commit an offence described in, this Schedule.

The present spate of US-initiated wars, threats of wars, embargoes, threats of embargoes, coups, threats of coups, heavy censorship and large propaganda, whereas spectacular in its breadth, appears to lack strategic coherence, tactical effectiveness, credibility or effectiveness.

ABOVE: An image circulated by CNN confirms the uncontrolled violence of the protesters. Even CNN appears a bit confused concerning the Hong Kong course of. The caption reads: A policeman seems on the injury and particles after protesters stormed the legislature hours earlier than in Hong Kong early on July 2, 2019. This picture was a part of a subtly tendentious dispatch filed by James Griffiths on 2 July 2019.

Look at it, when you can, and see in case you can spot the biases now that you simply learn our remedial report.

  • First revealed at Greanville Submit.
  • Godfree Roberts, Ed.D. Schooling & Geopolitics, College of Massachusetts, Amherst (1973), at present resides in Chiang Mai, Thailand. His experience covers many areas, from historical past, politics and economics of Asian nations, mainly China, to questions referring to know-how and even retirement in Thailand, a subject of particular pursuits for a lot of would-be Western expats inquisitive about relocating to locations the place a modest revenue can nonetheless guarantee an honest lifestyle and medical care. Learn different articles by Godfree.

    About the author

    Admin